I just bought a 627. they are cheaper than speed loader (moon clips) they are harder to load. I don't know how hard it will b to get empty case out yet. I think its going to be a pain. get a few moon clips and a few speed loaders. won't hurt to have both.
Unless you get ones that don't jiggle [fit tight,, case/ammo /clip specific] speed loiaders seem to do better.
The reason is the case length and the fact there is not a standard for the cut above the rim on standard rimed cases
a lit more fitting will be required.
Got a TRR8 with clips,,, don't use them as some cases fit ,some don't.
id did a 454 Alaskan once. Foolishly let a guy at work talk me out of it. It would shoot 454s or 45 colts with or without clips. If you used clips you had to use the thin ones they sold. I would also shoot 45acps using factory smith 25 clips. I wasn't all that accurate with acps and point of aim was so much different it wasn't really practical. I actually took it to a ppc shoot with full power 454s one day. Went up to the line without saying anything and started to shoot a round with 5 other shooters. Everyone on the range stopped. It scared the heck out of everyone. the range officer stopped the shooting and asked me what I was doing. they actually got a good laugh out of it. They let me shoot a round with it but they didn't put any one else on the line because who could consentrate with that cannon going off. At that time I had a 293/300 average and actually shot a 288 with it and took 6 place in the expert class. I don't shoot ppc anymore but stop by the matches on occasion and it never fails that someone brings that up and theres a good laugh. It sure would have made for a great bear protection gun if you buy into that stuff. In all actuality it was softer shooting then my two FA 454s were. Probably due to the rubber grips and the fact that the bullet didn't stay long in that 2.5 inch barrel. Sure was a flame thrower though
MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN! STEEL FOR TANKS NOT FENCES!!!
I have a Colt 1917 in.45 acp which uses clips. Don't care for the clip. It can be shot w/out the clips. I just got a Ruger Blackhawk .45/.45 acp instead of a Redhawk in.45/.45 acp because it has to use the clips. With the Blackhawk you just change cylinders. I like that better. Just my opinion.
there are tools available that make loading and unloading clips a snap. Big advantage to clips is there not mechanical. no need to turn or push a thing. Open your gun and drop them in. Another advantage at least to me is I can load up 50 or so clips and go to the range and pick my brass up in groups of 6. As to 44 mags when you have a conversion done they machine a grove in your cylinder to except clips. Cool thing is they machine it so your rounds still headspace right without them so you can still use your speed loaders or load each cylinder individually. Only down side to 44 mag/45 colt/454 or any rimmed cartridge that has the cylinder cut for clips is the grove cant be done deep and still allow you to use your gun without clips so clips are thin and much easier to bend or damage. Not so much there gong to bend in your pocket but if you don't use the proper tool to load and unload them its easy to bend them. I have had the push botton speed loaders empty in my pocket because the button was bumped. All that said theres nothing faster to reload a revolver with then a full moon clip.