Graybeard Outdoors banner

1 - 20 of 21 Posts

·
Administrator
Joined
·
26,026 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
https://gundigest.com/reviews/shotguns/affordable-overunder-shotguns

By Nick Sisley -September 22, 2017

Over/Under shotguns tend to cost a lot of money. But there are some affordable double-barreled gems available nearly any shooter can work into their budget.

What are some economical over/unders?

CZ Redhead Premier
CZ Sharp-Tail Side-By-Side
Mossberg Silver Reserve II
Savage Model 555
Browning Citori

There are over/under shotguns out there that cost more than I paid for our three-bedroom brick ranch house in 1961. These would be the likes of Krieghoff, Kolar, Perazzi and others. Similarly, there are used side-by-sides, especially old English types, that in current-day prices can cost as much as a Southern California fixer-upper. This is not about such double guns.

The game plan here is to tell you about several over/unders and a side-by-side that won’t break your bank, melt your plastic or get you in too much Dutch with your spouse. There aren’t too many hunters, upland specialists and waterfowlers who wouldn’t love to see a nice double gun in their gun safe — as well as be proud to carry one come November. So, let’s start with CZ-USA and their flagship hunting over/under shotgun.

CZ Redhead Premier



CZ is short for the Czech Republic company that the “C” and the “Z” in the company name are too hard for Americans to pronounce, so this is made simple with CZ — with CZ-USA the American importer of their many products. This company’s most traditional and most long-term products have to be their bolt-action centerfire rifles. But CZ also makes a complete line of rifles, plus Dan Wesson handguns and other firearms-related products. CZ’s many shotgun models are imported from Turkey.

But let’s get back to that CZ flagship over/under — the Redhead Premier. Of special interest, this model is not only available in 12, 20, 28 and .410 — each of these gauge receivers is delivered in their own size frame, which means the 12 gauge is made on one size receiver, the 20 on a smaller receiver and on down the line with the 28 and .410.

The CZ Redhead Premier features a bright satin receiver, a bit of engraving, as well as a classic-style Turkish walnut stock. Both the 12- and 20-gauge guns come in either 26- or 28-inch barrels, and five flush-mounted screw-in chokes are included — all at a suggested retail of less than a grand!

I missed the SHOT Show when the Turkish-made double guns were first introduced, then imported by a company called Armsco — the doubles made by Huglu in Turkey — the same maker that CZ now uses for their double-gun imports. But I did make the next SHOT Show, and the Armsco booth was the first I visited because I had been told of these over/unders and side-by-sides. I was so impressed that I eventually bought five of these doubles.

There’s fine laser-cut checkering on today’s CZ Redhead, a solid 8mm mid-rib (so no brush can accumulate while bulling thickets), a top rib, extractors and pistol grip that does not have a lot of re-curve. Thus, Prince of Wales style on that grip. There are 3-inch chambers in the 12, 20 and .410 CZ Redhead Premiers, with 2¾-inchers in the 28 bore. Both the 28 and the .410 come only with 28-inch barrels (probably CZ’s most popular length in all four gauges).

There’s a single extractor instead of ejectors on all gauges — plus the 12, 20 and 28 come with screw chokes, and the .410 with fixed Modified and Full. Those tight chokes, I think, are a mistake. Screw-in chokes or more open ones are required in the .410 for most shooters. Otherwise patterns are too tiny, especially at regular upland distances.



The length of pull has been updated at 14.5 inches, the drop at comb 1⅜ inches and the drop at heel is 2¼ inches. Triggers are mechanical, and the thumb safety is manual. Weight in the 12 gauge runs an average of 7.7 pounds, depending a bit on density of the walnut. Don’t expect a lot of walnut figure, but do expect wood strength.

What does a $12,000 over/under have over one like the CZ Redhead Premier that costs less than $1,000? The Redhead is a hunting gun, though it can be used plenty on any clay target field. Hunting guns are simply not shot all that much when compared to a competition over/under that might be shot 20,000 times per year for decades! I doubt the Redhead will hold up to that type of long-term punishment.

Plus, on a $14,000 shotgun, there tends to be better fit and finish — a higher grade of walnut — as well as many other factors that increase costs. Still, if you’re looking for a double gun that you want to hunt with, this CZ Redhead Premier and the others that will follow are definitely worth your consideration.

CZ Sharp-Tail Side-By-Side



While over/unders outsell side-by-sides by a large margin in America, there are those who feel that the side-by-side is the ultimate hunting gun. Many of the old English doubles can sell for over $100,000 — and they’re over 100 years old — so they weren’t made with modern stronger steels. This Sharp-Tail model is made with high-strength steel, and it sells for a pittance in comparison. Regardless, the gun comes with classic lines and classic appeal.

Further, the CZ Sharp-Tail is offered in 12, 20, 28 and .410 — each gauge built on its own size frame. Thus, the 28 gauge weighs only a whisper compared to the 12 gauge. But, even the 12 gauge is no heavyweight at 7 pounds, 3 ounces. All Sharp-Tails come with a 28-inch barrel only and extractors that lift both shells out for easy removal.

There’s a classic feel to these guns with splinter fore-end (though CZ calls it a semi-beavertail) and a semi-pistol grip stock of Turkish walnut. Swing one on an upland bird and your mind will maybe take you back into history 100 years. The 20 gauge and 28 gauge weigh 6.3 and 5.9 pounds, respectively. In my view, these are the gauges to select for upland shooting, and the 12 for waterfowl and turkeys. The .410 CZ Sharp-Tail also weighs in at 5.9 pounds. List price is right around $1,000.



Adding to this model’s appeal is the color case-hardened receiver finish. This is a new receiver compared to CZ side-by-sides of some years back — smaller and lighter, and probably stronger as well — and is forged in one piece. Trigger springs are now coil type. The trigger is a single, selectable one. Fine laser-cut checkering adorns the grip and slender fore-end. Five screw-in chokes are a part of the Sharp-Tail package (though fixed Modified and Full in the .410), and don’t forget the plastic protective case.

Three-inch chambers reside in the 12, 20 and .410, and a 2¾-inch in the 28 gauge. Barrels of both the CZ Sharp-Tail and CZ Redhead are black chromed on the outside (great for corrosion resistance), and inside there’s full-length chrome protection. Stock dimensions are 14.5 x 1.5 x 2.25 inches. There’s a raised rib, and the mechanical trigger has a selector for barrel choice. So, if a side-by-side has long been on your “I wanna” list, maybe you better check out a CZ dealer.

Mossberg’s Silver Reserve II



Love a great touch of engraving on a bright coin-finish receiver? Mossberg’s Silver Reserve II over/under will get your attention. Mossberg imports this one from Turkey, and in my mind, it brings up dreamy ideas of chasing native chukers somewhere in the Middle East.

However, this Mossberg over/under will be right at home whether you’re chasing ruffed grouse, Hungarian partridge, pheasants, woodcock, quail, doves — even pest pigeons. Gauge choices run the gamut here — though no 16 bores are offered. May I suggest a 20 gauge? All gauges come with five flush-mounted screw-in chokes that are compatible with Benelli and original Beretta Mobilechokes — except again for the .410’s fixed Modified and Full chokes.

Back to the engraving, which is wraparound scroll and plenty of it on the bright silver nitride receiver. Checkering on the pistol grip and slim fore-end of the Silver Reserve II is the cut type. The website suggests 7 pounds for the 20 gauge with 26-inch barrels. However, my test 20 hefts 6 pounds, 9 ounces on my digital postal scale.

Chambers are 3 inches in the 12, 20 and .410, and 2¾ inches for the 28 gauge. Length of pull is only 14 inches,which is a little short for most of today’s new guns but maybe just right for you. The stock is select Turkish walnut. There’s a vent rib with a front bead. The Field models come with extractors, but there’s a Sporting Silver Reserve II 12 gauge with ejectors.



Full retail price is $773 for the Field Model discussed here, but who pays full retail for most anything these days? I’ve already mentioned melted plastic credit cards and empty cookie jars, but neither need take place with this series of Mossberg Silver Reserve II over/unders.

Lockup is similar to the CZ Redhead Premier — with barrels pivoting on trunnions and a full-width locking bolt that slides forward upon closing to engage lugs milled into the bottom of the monobloc. Further, two recoil lugs milled into the base of the monobloc dovetail into milled-out areas in the bottom of the receiver upon closing, resulting in a very strong lockup. A barrel selector on the safety switch allows choice of the top or bottom barrel. Picture yourself in a field of South Dakota CRP, a Minnesota tangle of wrist-thick aspens, approaching an old apple tree in New England, or watching a pointer quarter back and forth on a Southern plantation of pines with the undergrowth burned over the previous spring — in each scenario you are carrying a highly engraved Mossberg Silver Reserve II over/under.

Savage/Stevens Model 555



Lightweight is the byword when it comes to the Savage/Stevens model 555 over/under because the receiver is not steel but high-strength aluminum alloy — but with a strength-enhancing steel insert at the breechface. Even the 12 gauge hefts only 6 pounds, the 20, 28 and .410 — 5.5 pounds — and each gauge is made to its own specific receiver size. These are the types of guns grouse and woodcock hunters seem to like because they want to carry their upland ordnance in a ready, somewhat port arms position full time … or at least for hours on end. Most of us can’t do that with a 7.5-pound shotgun. The heft of the smaller gauge 5.5-pound Stevens 555 makes such ready carrying easy.

The 12 gauge comes with a 28-inch barrel — the other three with a 26-incher. Barrels are rigged for flush-mounted screw chokes, with five of them included. The stock is Turkish walnut in a matte finish and the trigger is mechanical. There are extractors instead of ejectors, and there’s a manual safety — meaning the safety does not engage automatically when you open the gun. Lockup is similar to the previously described over/unders; barrels pivoting on trunnions — plus that full bolt based in the bottom of the receiver, and the strength-enhancing recoil lug. MSRP for the Stevens 555 starts at less than $700.

https://1s18w12tqveh1xfywp1ulx42-wpengine.netdna-ssl.com/wp-content/uploads/Savage-555-profile.jpg

There’s a vent rib with white bead at the muzzle; there are vented side panels, and the barrel wears a matte finish. The receiver and the fore-end iron are deeply blued — almost black. There’s cut checkering on the pistol grip and the fore-end — the latter Schnabel in style.

Mearns quail habitat in southern Arizona is some steep and thick cover. In my experience, they erupt with almost blinding speed — just the situation where a very lightweight shotgun can pay dividends. Why? Because in shooting scenarios like this, the bird’s jump has them already ahead of the barrels. So, the shooter must catch up — thus, the swing-through shooting technique is almost universally required here. The low weight of the Stevens 555 makes catching up easier.

Experienced swing-through shotgunners have a mantra as they are swinging to catch up: “Bum, Belly, Beak,” and “beak” is when they hit the trigger.

Browning Citori



Yes, we are moving up in price range with Browning’s Citori, but this over/under is a worthy consideration as the cost is relatively low compared to the quality, and so many of them have been sold that Citoris are readily available on the used market at less than retail prices. Further, these guns have performed on all the clay target stages — many of them for hundreds of thousands of rounds. So, you can rely on a Citori to hold up long term whether it’s new or used.

I’ve visited a number of firearms factories over the years, and most are basically sophisticated machine shops that turn out high-quality firearms. Visiting the Browning factory in Japan, I saw things differently. Sure, there was plenty of “machining” going on there, but what impressed me in that factory was the inordinate amount of handwork that goes into making a Citori.

The Citori is, in many ways, a knockoff of the Browning Superposed. It was made in Belgium for decades. In the early 1970s Browning brass saw the financial handwriting on the wall. Belgian labor costs were mushrooming, and who knows how much the machinery there was aging and in need of replacement. Thus, the move was made to Japan, and the model name went from Superposed to Citori.

For decades now the Browning Citori has become available in a near unimaginable series of models — mainly specialized renditions for trap, sporting clays and skeet. These are more expensive than the basic Citori, but the ensuing paragraphs are devoted only to the Citori.

Today’s basic model is the Citori Lightning — in style similar to the Superposed Lightning — with Lightning-style rounded fore-end and semi-pistol grip. The Lightning model Citori is offered in 12 gauge — and on a smaller, lighter receiver in 20, 28 and .410 — all three smaller gauges based on the 20-gauge receiver and thus of similar weight.



Further, there are Citori models with a steel receiver and those with an aluminum alloy, the latter offering almost a pound in weight reduction — this one dubbed the Citori Superlight. There’s even a White Lightning model with a bright silver nitride receiver. The basic Lightning receiver is richly blued. The current full retail is still under $2,000. You also get good quality engraving on the receiver and fore-end, engraving that closely resembles the engraving on the old Superposed.

The semi-pistol grip (again think Prince of Wales style) seems to offer quicker, surer gun mounting. Tight re-curve pistol grips are more suited to an already-mounted gun — as in clay target busting. The stock is gloss finished, and the checkering is cut very fine at 24 lines-to-the-inch. There is no recoil pad, which is important to a hunting gun, as less weight is involved with the Citori’s black plastic buttplate. Better balance is maintained, with the average balance point right at the hinge.

That “hinge” is also different in the Browning Citori compared to most all current-day over/unders. Barrels don’t pivot on trunnions but instead pivot on a full-width hinge pin. There’s also the full-width locking bolt and a recoil lug milled into the base of the monobloc that dovetails into a matching milled-out area in the bottom of the receiver — that recoil lug going all the way through the base of the receiver. Check out this square notch in the accompanying photo. This lockup design is extremely strong.


The 12 gauge tends to weigh a tad over 8 pounds with 28-inch barrels. Three screw chokes are included. Barrels are overbored to .74 inch. Chambers are 3 inches in the 12, 20 and .410, and 2¾ inches for the 28. The 12-bore Citori is also offered with 26-inch barrels, but the 20-gauge barrel possibilities are most interesting — 26, 28, 30 and 32 inches! With a 28-inch barrel, the 20 gauge goes 6 pounds, 9 ounces. Both the .410-bore and 28-gauge guns come with either 26- or 28-inch barrels. How about the 12-gauge in Mississippi at one of Nash Buckingham’s favorite waterfowl haunts? If the birds aren’t flying, you can always look down and admire the fit and finish of your Citori.

Want lighter weight? Then go with the Browning Citori Superlight models. These come with the alloy receiver, but the grip is straight and the fore-end features a bit of the Schnabel flare. More money is demanded here, but still a full retail of under $2,400. Other specs include: 26-inch barrels and 6 pounds, 12 ounces for the 12 gauge; and 5 pounds, 11 ounces for the 20 gauge. There are no 28s or .410s in the Superlight renditions. Receivers are bright silver nitride like the White Lightning — so expect even better corrosion resistance than a blued receiver. Check out Browning.com.

Editor’s Note: This article is an excerpt from Gun Digest 2018 available at GunDigestStore.com.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,714 Posts
Someone should explain the difference between an O/U and a SxS to Mr. Sisley! He says "What are some affordable O/U's" - and then proceeds to list the CZ Sharptail as one of them.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
357 Posts
He left out the Yildiz O/U as sold by Academy Sports. I know of two in use by very active huters and thier only complaint is recoil from the light weight. I have shot and examined them very closely and the quality of fit and finish is very good.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
4,960 Posts
IF, it doesn't have double triggers I don't want it.....no matter who built it!!


IF, it's a S&S, then it has to have a "splinter" for end too...


DM
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,714 Posts
I can tolerate a single trigger on an O/U, but all SxS's should have DT's.

A pet peeve of mine is the barrel selector incorporated in the safety - sooner or later you're going to get in a hurry and end up with it halfway between and it won't fire. There's absolutely no need to have a barrel selector on a single trigger gun - you'll never use it anyway.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,520 Posts
A Browning is considered affordable? A used Browning at the local gun shop is over 1400.00. I don't call that affodable compaired to the Mossberg and stevens/savage at half that price NEW.
He also left out the tri star line of OU shot guns far cheaper than a used Browning.


:D Al
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
650 Posts
...alas, the Stoeger Condor is an economical O/U not worthy of a shot. =(
I've read nothing but good things about the Stoeger Condor, so much so that I just bought a 12 ga Stoeger Condor Longfowler. I like OUs and wanted a new gun for doves and Turkey. Only shot it a couple times but it seems like a tight, well made (for the price ) gun.
I'll report back after I get more chances to use it.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
5,135 Posts
I had a Yildiz 20 400.00 out the door great gun well made also bought a stoeger condor 12 well made nice gun bought it at a gun show for 250.00 both of these guns are very under rated in my opion

Deaconllb
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
109 Posts
Great reviews guys.
My post about the Condor was a bit tongue-in-cheek, because it wasn't included in the list that is the subject of this thread, thus it must be "not worthy of a shot" (because the title states every gun in their list is "worth a shot").
FWIW, I've heard nothing but good things about any of the Stoeger guns and was surprised it wasn't included.
 

·
Administrator
Joined
·
26,026 Posts
Discussion Starter #11
Long years ago I think there were a lot of reported issues on the Condor. I've never owned one but have owned several Stoeger guns and had no complaints about those I had. I think I've owned them in 12, 20, 28 and .410 all.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,015 Posts
CZ

Not sure of the shotguns, but CZ has a cult like following amongst the .22 rimfire guys. While definitely not an O/U, I'd like to try a 20 gauge CZ Sharptail. Something you could take into the woods and thickets, let rain fall on it and not worry so much. The case hardened receiver lends a touch of class. My Win 101 has a single trigger with integrated barrel selector, doesn't seem an issue. I've wimped out before, wearing gloves fighting briars and had interference issues with a double trigger. Since then, only one glove on the non trigger hand. I do like an automated ejector though. That distinctive pop sound upon opening with the fired hull arching over the shoulder.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
5,135 Posts
Gun Rag Writers write what they are paid to right other wise it don't get printed I read the reports look the guns over and then decide what is best for me price also has to enter into the choice.


Deaconllb
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,714 Posts
I've only owned one Stoeger and that was a SxS coach gun. It worked fine, but the barrels didn't shoot anywhere near to the same point of aim. That's not really a knock against Stoeger, it's not an uncommon occurrence with lower priced doubles/over and unders. Likely the short (20") barrels contributed to the points of impact being so far apart.

Ejectors are nice, but I wouldn't want them on a gun with a price point lower than the Citori. They work fine on cheap single shots, but not so much on cheap doubles/over and unders.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
109 Posts
va rifleman,

The CZ's were carving out quite a reputation amongs the O/U & SxS crowd, then they "simplified" their line-up and all the chatter about them seemed to evaporate along with it.
I've only heard good things about the break actions and it seems the general consensus may still say its a preferred long gun.


-----------------------------------------------------


Greybeard,


I think I know what you're getting at.
I too can remember a time when the name "Stoeger" and "El Cheapo" were synonymous.
It seems they've turned themselves around over the years an now produce a pretty nice firearm....well, the shotguns anyway.
I'm sure, like a number of other companies, they're taking advantage of the inexpensive but well made arms that have been coming out of Turkey for the last 20 years.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,520 Posts
My brother in law recently bought a Mossy silver reserve 20ga.
Seems like a very well made shot gun and I can shoot it just fine. He how ever would be more comfortable with a fixed choke shot gun.
He keeps changeing the chokes from week to week and never seems to get comfortable with how much he needs to lead a target.

No I have Breattas with extractors single triggers and no barrel slectors and really like them. I have Charles Dalys with single triggers and ejectors ok when shooting clays as I can crack the action and catch the hulls be fore they going flying.

I get up set when I am suooting clays with a group and the hogs eject their hulls even with autos and won't police them to the trash cans placed at every station.

I have a SKB 885 it has a barrel slector I owned the shot gun (bought used) for a long time before i knew it. I have it set like all the other OU's bottom barrel fires first.

:D Al
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
357 Posts
I agree that a double barrel should have double triggers. Sadly my Yildiz does not. I had a 12ga Beretta O/U that had them, gave it to a nephew who sold it. I'm an idiot.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,714 Posts
Haven't looked at one of those, but the "kind of stiff to open" is pretty common among the Turkish made guns. Some individual specimens more so than others, even in the same brand. Not that big of a deal as they will smooth up with use, or you can speed up the process by using some fine polishing paste and working it open and closed.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
109 Posts
I agree with Spruce, but will expand that past Turkey.
My dad gave me a brand new Stevens 511 for Xmas in either '77 or '78.
I would've been either 14 or 15 years old at the time.
Only brand new gun I've ever owned.
It was stiff to open, too, but by the end of that first season, opening and closing wasn't nearly such a chore.
...thus, my advice...
Grab a few of those 100 round field and target loads they sell at Wally world for like $25 a pop and spend the weekend at the range.
Gun should be working very nicely by Monday.
 
1 - 20 of 21 Posts
Top