Joined
·
429 Posts
- Accuracy?
- Reliability?
- Field Grade vs Premier Grade?
- Barrel length?
- Customer service...if needed?
This gun's gonna cost more than my first truck :wink: so I want to make an informed decision.
Thanks.
SkyDancer said:My first 454 was a Freedom Arms 454 revolver. It could NOT hold up to the hard recoil. The underlug screw kept coming loose every 2 or 3 shots. I even used Loc-Tite and it still kept coing apart. When I examined the screw and measured it I found that though there were perhaps a 4 to 5 threads it could only be held by the bottom most thread since the receiving hole was threaded to begin much to deep.
Also, the grip screw kept coimg loose as well. And last but not least the rear sight set screws were always coming loose every few shots.
So I went to a Raging Bull and I have owned three of them since my FA days. All of them performed flawlesly and all are as accurate as ****.
I have also ownedthe Magnum Research BFR 454 and this revolver was equisitely robust as well. I'd take these two over the FA 454 any day of teh week.
Lloyd Smale said:But I did own a bfr in .480 and I wouldnt trade you a ruger for another one......One thing that you have to do constantly with a big bore gun is check the screws I check the ones on my linebaugh built guns about every 50 shots....
Every 50 shots is one thing...every 3 shots is another. So I disagree with you. If FA is going to charge $1272 for their .454 [at that time] then their quality assurance process should have been good enough to catch the lemon. I shouldn't have to wait again while they take their time trying to ascertain their QA problem. :x
As for your BFR .480 and not trading a Ruger for another one....according to MRI all BFR's are designed from modified Ruger Blackhawk frames. I owned the 45-70 BFR and 45 Colt P+ BFR and I would take the robustness of the entire BFR line anyday over the FA. :?
SkyDancer said:For those FA enthusiasts...
I have owned 454 in Ruger SRH, FA, MRI BFR and Taurus Raging Bull. Of all of them only the FA had loosening problems with the screws. None of the others have ever loosened and I have fired at least 2000 rounds through them without a need to tighten up any screws. And yes I check with each session to make sure.
As for QA, I have had to send my RB and BFI back for problems unrelated to their power affects and I have received brand new guns in each instance. That is more than I can say for FA.
Sorry folks...I will never purchase another firearm from FA as long as there are other companies making the same caliber in what certainly appears to me to be more robust in their construction.
I just wonder how much of the hype about FA is based on buying the "label" rather than on a true apples-to-apples comparison of quality
and perfomance.
And yes we will always agree to disagree on this matter because my experience is based on actually owning and firing ALL of the firearms in question...not just owning one and / or reading reviews about them in the gun rags by someone who tested any in a limited capacity.
:roll:
I shoot the following:MS Hitman said:What other cartridges do you shoot?