Kinda hard to beat a Browning BPS. Low cost, high utility, high quality, ambidextrous, weather resistant, good support in case repairs are needed, the list goes on. It's what the Remington 870 has the reputation of being-- one of the finest guns money can buy. No sense in spending a lot on this kind of gun unless you plan on using it a great deal. If that were the case, then maybe one of the synthetic stocked autos would be a good choice. I liked the ergonomics of the Benelli Super Black Eagle.